You guys answer me a debate

Gnomercy · 02-19-2004

between a guildie of mine please.

All things being equal excpet AC and HP( and AC isnt around the 2200 mark yet) which would be a better item.

A 30ac 100hp or
A 10ac 130hp item

PS Chuck when these guys prove me right you owe me the 4 regura claws and if by chance im wronk i already have a few cracked for yu in the bank

Archonfire · 02-19-2004

30 ac 100 hp, by far imo.

Until late in the 2200's ac still gives a significant boost to mitigation/avoidance, I believe.

I know for sure it's still doing big stuff for me at just below 2200.

minet · 02-19-2004

i would do 30 ac 100 hp

Dakryn · 02-19-2004

Is this the Gnomercy I think it is?
Anyway
Yeah 30 AC 100hp > 10ac 130hp
20ac>30hp

Goradain · 02-19-2004

Yep

Barja Bardagi · 02-19-2004

Same, 20ac > 30HP

Fitemore · 02-19-2004

Yup. See above. Not even a contest.

turkishbull · 02-19-2004

im gonna have to agree with everyone else 30 AC 100 HP much better

**Brutul** · 02-19-2004

20 ac vs 30 hps isn't even a tough decision. If it was 20 ac vs 100 hps you might have to think twice about it.

Gnomercy · 02-19-2004

Thanks all..this is more than enough info for me to win my claws. hello fresh batch of Bristlebanes party platters

Surlok · 02-19-2004

I had a acrylia embedded visor 40 ac 100 hp and I refused to rpealce it till time even with a fennin mask available at 20 ac 150 hp.

I jsut couldn't justify losing that much hp for a small hp upgrade.

Klaenie · 02-20-2004

Quote:

I jsut couldn't justify losing that much hp for a small hp upgrade.

Someone musta been tired when he wrote that.

Helana

Grendonbb · 02-20-2004

Ya, lol.

Ever since SoE fixed ac a few expansions ago, it has climbed the ladder of importance again. 20 ac is far far far greater than 30 hps. Don't even think about it.

Surlok · 02-21-2004

Quote:

Someone musta been tired when he wrote that

Just my luck I get a week of of overtime at work the same week the new expansion goes live,and I am the warrior CO and exptected to be on everyday..Thank god the overtime is over and the entire guild is Kod'Taz flagged ..I can thnk a little more clearly now....

And yeah I meant could not justify losing that much "AC' over a small HP upgrade.

Wudgurorm · 02-24-2004

I have been siding in favor of AC lately within reason 10 to 40 hp is reasonable to me.

02-19-2004	#1
Gnomercy Veteran User Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: Jackson Ms Age: 41 Posts: 16 Rep Power: 0	You guys answer me a debate between a guildie of mine please. All things being equal excpet AC and HP( and AC isnt around the 2200 mark yet) which would be a better item. A 30ac 100hp or A 10ac 130hp item PS Chuck when these guys prove me right you owe me the 4 regura claws and if by chance im wronk i already have a few cracked for yu in the bank

02-19-2004	#4
Dakryn is Hardcore Join Date: Jul 2003 Location: MCAS Yuma Posts: 376 Rep Power: 20	Is this the Gnomercy I think it is? Anyway Yeah 30 AC 100hp > 10ac 130hp 20ac>30hp __________________ Dakryn Valduryn Warrior - Xeth Dakryn Val'Duryn Warrior - Everquest RIP 2005

02-19-2004	#5
Goradain Veteran User Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: Wichita Age: 37 Posts: 320 Rep Power: 20	Yep __________________ Goradain - Jedi-Overlord of Rallos Zek "Where's the kaboom? There was supposed to be an earth-shattering kaboom."

02-19-2004	#6
Barja Bardagi knows that Warriors are superior Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Cazic-Thule Age: 40 Posts: 74 Rep Power: 21	Same, 20ac > 30HP __________________ Barja Bardagi The Relentless The M&M's Shell

02-19-2004	#7
Fitemore knows too much Join Date: Mar 2003 Posts: 1,047 Rep Power: 22	Yup. See above. Not even a contest. __________________ Fitemore Mystique "You see he stand 'bout six foot four All the downtown ladies call him 'Treetop Lover' All the mens just call him 'Sir' " -Jim Croce

02-19-2004	#2
Archonfire Veteran User Join Date: Sep 2003 Location: Fort Riley Age: 31 Posts: 26 Rep Power: 0	30 ac 100 hp, by far imo. Until late in the 2200's ac still gives a significant boost to mitigation/avoidance, I believe. I know for sure it's still doing big stuff for me at just below 2200.

02-19-2004	#3
minet Veteran User Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: midwest usa Posts: 95 Rep Power: 19	i would do 30 ac 100 hp

02-19-2004	#8
turkishbull dead man walking Join Date: Jun 2003 Age: 40 Posts: 327 Rep Power: 0	im gonna have to agree with everyone else 30 AC 100 HP much better

02-19-2004	#9
Brutul Slayer of Whiners Join Date: Mar 2003 Location: Livermore, CA Age: 36 Posts: 5,452 Rep Power: 26	20 ac vs 30 hps isn't even a tough decision. If it was 20 ac vs 100 hps you might have to think twice about it. __________________ Brutul Vilesilencer..........Brutul Vilesilencer Barbarian Vanquisher.....Retired Overlord Test Server....................Tarew Marr cleric bot

02-19-2004	#11
Surlok Surly Barbarian Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Halas Posts: 357 Rep Power: 21	I had a acrylia embedded visor 40 ac 100 hp and I refused to rpealce it till time even with a fennin mask available at 20 ac 150 hp. I jsut couldn't justify losing that much hp for a small hp upgrade. __________________ -1 Battered and bloody, Suit of armor Warrior Spirit not included

02-20-2004	#13
Grendonbb Banned...or am I? Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Gahanna, Ohio Posts: 492 Rep Power: 21	Ya, lol. Ever since SoE fixed ac a few expansions ago, it has climbed the ladder of importance again. 20 ac is far far far greater than 30 hps. Don't even think about it. __________________ Half-Elf (Half-Ogre) Grendon's Stuff Retired Member of Familjen Bristlebane Server ************************************************ ********************* "I personally have not used one, but I am have been unimpressed with the agro from a BoW." ********************************************** ***********************

02-24-2004	#15
Wudgurorm Veteran User Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Tennessee Age: 40 Posts: 68 Rep Power: 21	I have been siding in favor of AC lately within reason 10 to 40 hp is reasonable to me.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Can you guys look me over quick?	kjelrod	The Bunker	9	04-26-2005 09:16 AM
Hi Guys. First Time Poster	pierre109	The Bunker	13	03-19-2005 12:19 PM
Hi Guys	Mihtee	The Arena	12	09-13-2004 06:13 AM
Searched/Library, no answer..	Drekalf Goreu	The Arena	12	05-06-2004 10:03 AM


The Steel Warrior Advertisement


The Steel Warrior Advertisement

You guys answer me a debate

The Overlords Sanctuary